Planetary News: SETI (2001)
The "Wow!" Signal Still Eludes Detection
By Amir Alexander
17 January, 2001
The Wow Signal
The computer printout of the "Wow!" signal, along with Jerry Ehman's famous comment.
Credit: The Big Ear Observatory
|
Whatever happened to the "Wow!" signal, the most promising
transmission from space ever detected by SETI? Ever since it was recorded
almost a quarter of a century ago, SETI enthusiasts have speculated about
its origin and wondered whether it could be a beacon from an alien civilization.
The latest attempt to relocate the signal, reported in the January 10
issue of the Astrophysical Journal, was led by longtime SETI researcher
Robert Gray with funding from The Planetary Society. But although
Gray and his team used the entire Very Large Array in New Mexico, and
although they detected many faint objects in the signal's general vicinity,
they found no trace of an alien transmission. As of now, the "Wow"
signal remains as enigmatic as ever..
The most famous signal in SETI history was detected on the night of August
15, 1977 at the Ohio State University Big Ear Observatory. As on every
other night, while Big Ear was searching the skies for an alien signal,
its observations were being recorded on a printout sheet. A long list
of letters and numbers was continuously being churned out, one long string
for every one of the fifty channels scanned by the telescope. A series
of characters appeared recording an unusual transmission at the frequency
of channel 2: "6EQUJ5" the list read. This startled Big Ear
volunteer Jerry Ehman, a professor at Franklin University in Columbus,
who was monitoring the readings that night. He circled the code for later
reference and added a single comment in the margins" "Wow!"
The signal entered SETI lore as the "Wow!" signal.
The series "6EQUJ5" described the strength of the received signal
over a short time-span. In the system used at the time at Big Ear, each
number from 1 to 9 represented the signal level above the background noise.
In order to extend the scale, the staff added letters, with each one from
A to Z representing increasingly stronger signal levels. 6EQUJ5 represented
a signal that grew in strength to level "U," and then gradually
subsides. In more familiar notation, the signal increased from zero to
level 30 "sigmas" above the background noise, and then decreased
again to zero, all in the span of 37 seconds.
Two
aspects of this signal immediately caught the attention of Ehman and project
director John Kraus, who saw the results the following morning. First
of all, 37 seconds was precisely the time it takes the Big Ear scanning
beam to survey a given point in the heavens. Because of this, any signal
coming from space would follow precisely the "Wow!" signal's
pattern - increasing and then decreasing over 37 seconds. This practically
ruled out the possibility that the signal was the result of Earthly radio
interference.
Big Ear
The Big Ear Radio Telescope at Ohio State University, as it appeared before its demolition in 1998.
Credit: The Big Ear Observatory
|
Secondly, the signal was not continuous, but intermittent. Kraus and Ehman knew
that, because Big Ear has two separate beams that scan the same area of
the sky in succession, several minutes apart. But the signal appeared
on only one of the beams and not on the other, indicating that it had
been "turned off" between the two scans. A strong, focused,
and intermittent signal coming from outer space: could it be that Big
Ear had detected an alien signal?
For a month following the discovery the Big Ear crew tried repeatedly to relocate
the signal, but to no avail. In 1987 and again in 1989 Robert Gray led
"Wow!" searches using the 84 foot radio telescope of the Planetary
Society-funded META array at the Oak Ridge Observatory in Massachusetts,
but found nothing. For his latest "Wow!" hunt Gray managed to
secure the services of the entire Very Large Array in New Mexico, composed
of twenty seven 25-meter dishes. This, according to Gray, was a first:
"Contrary to popular belief since the movie Contact," he emphasizes,
"the prestigious $80 million telescope hardly ever listens for broadcasts
from the stars."
During two observing sessions in 1995 and 1996 Gray and his colleague, Kevin
B. Marvel, used their telescope time to investigate several scenarios.
One possibility was that the "Wow!" signal in fact represents
a weak but steady transmission that momentarily gained in strength due
to interstellar scintillation. The high sensitivity of the VLA guaranteed
that such a source would be easily detected by Gray's survey. But despite
identifying several radio sources hundreds of times weaker than the "Wow!"
signal in the vicinity, nothing resembling a steady transmission was found.
Another scenario assumed that "Wow!" was a brief powerful signal designed
to attract attention to a weaker continuous one. Such a strategy would
be more energy efficient than sending a continuous powerful beacon. But
again, the VLA could detect no signal even 1000 times weaker than the
The Very Large Array (VLA)
The VLA is an NRAO (National Radio Astronomy Observatory) facility in the plains of St. Augustin, New Mexico. It is composed of 27 dishes, each 25 meters in diameter.
Credit: NRAO
| original signal.
Finally there is the possibility that the signal is there, but is only broadcast
intermittently. Because of their limited telescope time, Gray and Marvel
could only devote less than an hour to any given position. It could be
that the signal is on at other times, when no one is listening. The problem
is in fact unavoidable from any location in the Northern Hemisphere, since
the "Wow!" locale is below the Northern horizon during most
of the day. To account for that possibility, Gray joined forces with Simon
Ellingsen of the University of Tasmania, who will be able to track the
area for 14 hours at a time.
To this day we do not know the source of the strongest and clearest signal
ever to come through on a SETI search. Since it was undoubtedly artificial,
and almost certainly of celestial origin, Jerry Kraus speculates that
it may have come from a space probe (human space probe, that is
)
that he and the Big Ear staff were not aware of. That would certainly
make it an intelligent celestial signal, but not an alien one. And still,
there is always the possibility that it was something else - a true signal
from an alien civilization. Unless the signal is detected again, we may
never know for sure.
To learn more about Robert Gray's search for the "Wow!" signal,
see his article in the January/February 2001 issue of The
Planetary Report.
|